Hello
if it makes you feel any better i almost never hit the ball dead center.
Could it be pin elevation throwing your shot off?... have to compensate for that.
i play the beach course rather than bethpage... bethpage has some challenging elevation shots... 30+ elevation + wind etc with a bad shot like mine, your not always on spot lol.....i lose alot of perfectly good balls that way :o(
Not sure that will help since you been around longer than me ...i try to go back sometimes to tutorials and forums to maybe re learn to putt , judge distances and pin elevation ..... just to see if i missed something that can help my game in any way
Find your happy place