Best bet is corded mouse. If using a USB make sure batteries are topped off, or it's fully charged if it's a rechargeable model. I have one that will connect either USB or BlueTooth, I find I get better results from the USB mode. You can always double check all your mouse settings in Windows and make sure something hasn't changed.
I know some models have adjustable "click sensitivity" for buttons/wheel, so yours could be turned way down (although since you've tried different "mouses" 😂 I would doubt that's your issue).