Forums

Help › Forums

Country Club League - Autumn 2010 Season

Mon, Jan 10 2011 11:23 AM (497 replies)
  • Lisa03
    5,910 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 8:25 AM

    Take away Pts for previous matches?

    To Consider UK Golfers Elite as a Null factor in a pts. system would be fair if and only if UK GE teams A & B were scheduled to play every other team in the League.

    Since pts are awarded for participation, all teams must have an equal number of games in order to create a level playing field. If in fact UK GE (A & B) was on every clubs schedule---either nulification by DQ or foreiture of all matches will have the same effect.

    If ( as in Electra's case), UK GE A & B, were both scheduled to play a club, that club is 10 games short of a season. The whole concept of league play is dependent on each team participation---the lack of interest on the part of 1 club always impacts the entire league.

    The best that we can hope for at this point is that Mikem and Steely will step up and play or atleast explain why they are MIA.

  • lvietri
    3,326 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 8:30 AM

    Slor --- while Claremoreblue may be a touch off on his facts (not sure it's that many blue) truth is ... we worked hard to set up and play the matches.    Also .. i would recommend you take another look at the schedule as our club and Old Log Cabin will not have the same amount of "Ties" played at the end of the regular season as some of the others since we are not scheduled to play each other ... and pulling out UK B team puts us a Tie short of the others.

    The Competition is fun ... the matches are great ... and I understand it's hard to organize these leagues (god knows I couldn't do it)  But with your track record I was hoping you were going to have a bit more time to organize the league ... .   It's all over the floor.

    Doubtful we will sign up next season.

  • mikem77
    1,218 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 3:01 PM

    slor

    its took 2 weeks to play the rockandrollrastas b   team which wasnt our fault if you want us out of the league just say so ..some of these teams are great at sending you there team sheet but when it comes to there players arranging matches they seem to turn into lord lucan...the players i post to play are online usually everyday unlike some of our opponents in the past ..we can ;play 2 matches this week if required to catch up ,i will leave the decision with you but dont remember me asking you to boot a team out when our team was waiting for team fixtures ...i really think you have tried very hard to make this work but i suggest for your winter league you make all home teams post there team on a forum post  mondays and all away teams to reply with there team on the same post by tuesday,,then you would have 5 days to arrange and play the match ..

    as for the b team i would have to ask them as steely is on holiday

    mike

  • mikem77
    1,218 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 3:26 PM

    RnRR Team B VS UKGE77

    ST.A front 9: Pins- hard, Tees- white, Greens- VF, Wind- mod

    1. mojomango v script....... won
    2. hans43 vbillhorseman...won
    3. threedot v cowpen..........lost
    4. sarpsborg v  carlosjackal..won
    5. kwfegan v minkywinkster...won

    we beat the rastas b 4-1

    mike

  • slor
    902 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 3:32 PM

    Thanks for all your replies and I hear all of you.

    As the league is new, I don't like the idea of making clubs feel that they are being dealt with harshly or unfairly. And I especially didn't want clubs in the first couple of weeks finding their feet feeling that way.

    Although I thought that the fairest way of resolving a team going dormant, which is what appeared to be happening with the UK Golfers Elite A and B teams, is to take all their results off of the league, which is the way almost every league handles it,

    the effort made to organise matches should be rewarded even if it is unfair to the teams that had yet to play them and therefore never had the opportunity to take points from those matches.

    I did not think it through, and I apologise to everyone involved for it - making rules on the fly is very difficult and it's not something that I wish to do.

    So, as for the UK Golfers Elite A and B teams, yes, do attempt to catch up on matches, but I will start to entertain petitions for forfeits on a case-by-case basis, and the teams that you have stood up the last few weeks, including my own, have a pretty good case as things stand. If they are unable to find a time to play you in the next month, I wouldn't be finding much fault with them. However, I don't wish to make taking a forfeit to be too rewarding as I still want matches to be played, so a forfeit if it happens will be 3-0, or 6pts to the team.

     

  • slor
    902 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 3:50 PM

    Just to clarify, every team does play every other team once on the league schedule. The number of postponements may obscure this. My original thought to make it so all teams hadn't played them seemed like to most fair solution, but it's not the right one, as outlined above.

    Lisa03:

    Take away Pts for previous matches?

    To Consider UK Golfers Elite as a Null factor in a pts. system would be fair if and only if UK GE teams A & B were scheduled to play every other team in the League.

     

  • mikem77
    1,218 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 4:14 PM

    "Electra v uk elite a

    We have 5 ready to go. St Andrews Bk9 Gold Tees, easy pins, low wind, very fast green Nice and equal for Pros and Masters

    1. Priestess  v adeypa

    2. briobrio  v billhorseman

    3. Kurtsbuford  v minkywinkster

    4. Beryman v carlosjackal

    5. RUSaved v skaramanga

    asap guys electra are waiting 

    thanks mike

     

  • HughJass204
    266 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 4:31 PM

    Hi Slor

    As a member of UKGE B team I ask that you give us a couple of days grace. Our captain has not been online for some time so I will try and rustle up some interest and get back to you. Please let me know what order games are outstanding and I will see what I can do, scheduling 2 games a week

    Regards

    Hugh

  • lvietri
    3,326 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 7:34 PM

    thanks hugh .. i left our lineup on your profile wall ... just tell me where we will play  and who will playing  from  your team and i'll push our guys to set up the matches.

    Thanks,

  • Lisa03
    5,910 Posts
    Sun, Nov 21 2010 8:43 PM

    Thank you Hugh, I posted our players and the settings for the make-up Match vs Electra. (On your wall) as soon as I get your line-up, Iwill PM our players to schedule match.

RSS