Forums

SATG vs Scoundrels and Wenches

• SuperKanga 3,628 Posts

  Mon, Mar 24 2014 2:39 PM

  Thank you Erin :))

  That is very gracious of you.

  I can see how you would be confused as nobody posted the win for you to see.

  It was posted in our forum by Ingrid, but if Brady didn't post it for you, then obviously the confusion was there.

  Thank you for the congrats, but like I said...this was so not about the win...the whole comp has been fantastic, and lots of new friendships forged :))

  Thank you to members of both sides that participated, and I hope we can do it again very soon :))

  Rob :))

• tayty34 176 Posts

  Mon, Mar 24 2014 3:39 PM

  I have A BIG problem with Brady losing his match and then jolting to your club SK. I for one thing that match should be voided off the page. I dont care if we win or lose , I just do not like the way this played out at all. I'm sure you can see my point sir.

   

  Thanks

• tayty34 176 Posts

  Mon, Mar 24 2014 3:42 PM

  SuperKanga:

  For the sake of friendship and fair play Erin...please reconsider this.

  It doesn't matter which CC wins or loses, but your decision to cancel out Ingrid & Brady's game purely because Brady switched CC's has rubbed quite a few people the wrong way.

  Here is proof that Brady had left your CC before applying for membership to mine :-

  

  Going by your line of thinking on this, do we also "scratch" the match between Mohaviegreen & Snakeybite because Mo left OUR CC?

  I wouldn't think so.

  It's been a wonderful tourney with lots of new friendships forged...let's not spoil it all?

  Regards,

  Rob :))

  If Mo left your club and came to ours right after losing the CC V CC match, then yes I would say the same thing.

• SuperKanga 3,628 Posts

  Tue, Mar 25 2014 12:59 AM

  tayty34:

  I have A BIG problem with Brady losing his match and then jolting to your club SK. I for one thing that match should be voided off the page. I dont care if we win or lose , I just do not like the way this played out at all. I'm sure you can see my point sir.

   

  Thanks

  No Sir,

  I can NOT see your point at all.

  What you are implying is that Brady possibly "threw" the match in Ingrid's favour because he intended to switch to our CC?

  I find that an offensive implication.

  I don't even know the man...we've never met...but I know how I would feel if it was ME you were accusing of such a silly thing.

  Surely, winning or losing our matches wasn't important enough to ANY of us on either side to even contemplate doing such a thing?

  As far as I'm concerned, the object of the whole exercise was for 2 CC's to come together to play in friendly competition against each other, and hopefully forge new friendships. I see it as the objective fulfilled.

  Just a shame there is always one who wishes to "stir the pot" 

  Rob

• SuperKanga 3,628 Posts

  Tue, Mar 25 2014 1:03 AM

  tayty34:

  If Mo left your club and came to ours right after losing the CC V CC match, then yes I would say the same thing.

   

  And I would totally disagree with that statement too.

  The way I look at it is, that regardless of where Mo & Brady decided to go after their matches, they both represented their respective CC's to the best of their abilities.

  End of story...Sir

  Rob

• tayty34 176 Posts

  Tue, Mar 25 2014 1:34 PM

  SuperKanga:

  tayty34:

  If Mo left your club and came to ours right after losing the CC V CC match, then yes I would say the same thing.

   

  And I would totally disagree with that statement too.

  The way I look at it is, that regardless of where Mo & Brady decided to go after their matches, they both represented their respective CC's to the best of their abilities.

  End of story...Sir

  Rob

  We can both agree to disagree then. I just think the way it all went down was not in the spirit of what this match was about. I never said the guy lost his match on purpose , nor did I say he did not, I just think that leaving our club and jumping to your club directly after he lost his match and the fact the match was not reported to us smells funny to me. I'm not stiring the pot, I just want to get to the bottom of the pot.But since our Club owner decided to let it go, then I will obide by her decision even if I do not agree with it.

• boopers88 337 Posts

  Wed, Mar 26 2014 4:31 AM

  smart man lol great matches yall and end of story 

• MelissaNJohnson 158 Posts

  Wed, Mar 26 2014 9:16 AM

  Hopefully the bullcrap will STOP on this thread now, but I'm gonna add 2 things that I want to say.  First of all, I have friends in S&W and I am thankful for them everyday, you have gained a great player with Brady REGARDLESS of whether or not he "threw" his match. There's no proof as to whether or not he did or didn't just that he LOST to Ingrid.  Second topic, WHY would you save a screen shot showing that Brady LEFT our CC before requesting to join yours??? ANYONE that has been on this game for ANY length of time knows that you have to LEAVE one CC to join another one, so that screen shot is USELESS to prove anything!

  I am on this game to MAKE FRIENDS and have fun, but this bickering over BRADY..who I notice has chosen NOT to defend his actions on here is purely ridiculous.  I'm hoping that Tayty and Kanga realize how bad they are making their respective CC's look by sitting on here arguing like children. There's no need for ANY of this, it's done, it's in the past and NO ONE can change it so just STOP for crying out loud!

• EnriccoP 3,767 Posts

  Wed, Mar 26 2014 12:04 PM

  

• SuperKanga 3,628 Posts

  Wed, Mar 26 2014 12:39 PM

  MelissaNJohnson:

  ANYONE that has been on this game for ANY length of time knows that you have to LEAVE one CC to join another one, so that screen shot is USELESS to prove anything!

  While I agree with most of what you say Melissa, your statement above is quite wrong.

  I posted the screenshot to prove that I didn't send him a CC invite, which you CAN do when someone is already a member of another CC.

  So yes, time to put this to bed and get back to the serious business of having fun :))

  Rob :))