MBaggese: From the tips I tee off with 3 wood and stay in the fairway...usually have 170-ish to the pin
Same here.
But if I have a head wind, I'll use my driver at about 90%. My typical approach is the same as yours... about 170-175 yards. While that's a fairly long approach, the green tends to hold shots rather well, if playing a decent ball. I would say that I par it on a fairly regular basis. And every once in a while (about 10 to 15% of the time), I happen to get it close and manage a birdie.