I use a Microsoft optical mouse, have done for years. They ain't flash but they last forever and do the job.
I'm not sure how a super responsive mouse will help you here. You have all the time you need to aim and draw back the meter, as long as it registers the click fairly speedily, I don't see what difference you're really going to get. I'm fairly sure more bad shots are caused by meter issues than a mouse that takes 1/100 second longer to react to you clicking.
And I reckon even more are down to player error.