YankeeJim:
godelescher: but there are times when you need as much loft as possible, whether to control the roll or to clear the lip, or both.
You don't get much higher than a flop. That 1/4 swing is just plain bad news- an invitation for trouble.
I couldn't use Cabo as a demo, so I chose Oakmont 16 which has a similar deep bunker and not a lot of room in front.
In the first replay, I used a 64 degree wedge, full swing, 30-40% power. The lie was 40-50% buried.
In the second replay, I used a 60 degree wedge, flop shot, full power. The lie was slightly better at 30-40%
The partial power - full swing shot is slightly higher. If anything, because of the slightly better lie, the flop should have had a slight advantage in this test.
full swing
flop shot
You may be right that using the same club, a flop will fly higher, but the extra distance of a full swing allows me to use a higher lofted club.