Forums

Help › Forums

Re: Legends Merion Challenge

Mon, Jun 10 2013 9:52 PM (27 replies)
  • MBaggese
    15,368 Posts
    Sun, Jun 9 2013 2:00 PM

    Anyone notice only 78 posted scores for this tourney...if top 50% were to advance...shouldn't that have been 39 players?...I see only 28 players advanced.

     

    Am I looking at something incorrectly?

     

    Edit:

     

    NM...I see only 62 posted cores...three tied at 28...which makes 1/2 the field 31 players.

  • ColumbusStorm
    3,418 Posts
    Sun, Jun 9 2013 9:26 PM

    MBaggese:

    NM...I see only 62 posted cores...three tied at 28...which makes 1/2 the field 31 players.

    I noticed that too, 62 scores posted and 31 made the cut. The cut line was at 63, but only some of the 63's made the cut, thought all ties should make the cut. Assume WGT used their tie breaker system to cut some of the 63's.

  • MBaggese
    15,368 Posts
    Sun, Jun 9 2013 9:59 PM

    ColumbusStorm:
    noticed that too, 62 scores posted

     

    Yes, seems odd as UEL RG's filled fast enough at Beth and SA (open ones).

  • devonnnnn
    1,085 Posts
    Mon, Jun 10 2013 2:21 AM

    duffer19:

    I didn't do well either, but I honestly enjoyed every shot I had to make!  Keep em coming.

    i'd like to see a weekly 2 rounder of the same format.

    This is really needed. Played crap second round but had alot of fun with the event. Thanks WGT!

  • Corwyn
    2,410 Posts
    Mon, Jun 10 2013 6:52 AM

    I just want to add my gratitude for this great uneven lies tourney. Thank you WGT!

    I really enjoyed the challenge of playing Merion with unevens alongside the best of the best. It's a great course in these tough conditions, really forcing you to consider all your shots, and the risks involved. 

    I'd love to see a similar-format special Uneven Lies tourney every month (every 2 weeks might be too often to keep this as something unique and special, IMO), picking a course to correspond in some way with a key real-life tournament if possible (e.g. July could be a links course St A's or RSG to coincide with the British Open). 

    A few minor suggestions:

    1. A return to a split weekday/weekend schedule, which you used in the January uneven lies Invitationals, which ran from maybe Tues-Sat, and then the final round from Sun-Mon. The overlap with the weekend allowed players who could only play weekdays or weekends to get both rounds in easily. Running it Tues-Fri, and then Sat-Sun makes it hard for a lot of us.

    2. Could it be a cut-line of 50% + ties, rather than just 50%? Missing out on the tie-breaker is an awfully cruel way to be eliminated. And, looking at the TL division, it's striking that a lot of 1st-round 63s missed the cut, yet the eventual winner (congrats fm!) was just 2 shots better on 1st round.

    [BTW: I love that the winner was the player who produced the best single-play round (by 4 shots) in the harder conditions, and who was 4 shots back after the unlimited, perhaps proving that endless grinding for the top 1st round score is not essential! And I'm also stunned by how many WDs there were amongst the TLs: I'm guessing that a lot of players assumed many birdies were needed for a decent finish, and might have given up early. But, in this format, a cool head and lots of patience are critical.]

    3. Can there be more clarity on the format? A number of players didn't realize the unlimited 1st round (which I'd prefer it wasn't, but I understand WGT may need to do it that way for 'ball use' to help subsidize the doubled prize fund)... was going to count towards the final aggregate score.

    Using the phrase 'qualifier round' is confusing: "This free tournament is a week-long challenge with an unlimited-play qualifier round from 6/3-6/7". How about: "This free tournament is a week-long challenge with aggregate scores from an unlimited-play qualifier 1st round from x/x-x/x, and the top 50% + ties advancing to a single-play championship 2nd round, x/x-x/x."

    -------------

    Finally, congratulations to Hanswurst72 (for a runaway win in the Legends division), and to fmagnets (for winning the TL division; and commiserations bullfrog, for coming so close). 

  • Wontonamo
    2,269 Posts
    Mon, Jun 10 2013 5:41 PM

    Play the unlimited qualifier round from 6/10-6/14 and the top 50% in each tier advance to a single-play championship weekend round, 6/15-6/16 to post final combined scores. The top 70 players per tier win.

    thats the wording on the new merion challenge - me comprende now tyvm!

  • thebigeasy707
    5,885 Posts
    Mon, Jun 10 2013 7:12 PM

    have tried to play this new Merion Nation Tourney in heavy winds & game goes so many holes then hangs...

    furthest I've managed to get before it hangs is the 10th green after about 10 tries...usually it sticks cause of a jpg loading error after hole 3 or 4.

    no point wasting any more ball hits on it tonight...obviously wgt's experiencing an issue.....it happens from time to time :)

  • bhoese
    679 Posts
    Mon, Jun 10 2013 9:52 PM

    MBaggese:

    ColumbusStorm:
    noticed that too, 62 scores posted

     

    Yes, seems odd as UEL RG's filled fast enough at Beth and SA (open ones).

     

    They filed nice and fast on just about any course until it became clear that the VUSO would not be played with unevens.  

RSS