Forums

Help › Forums

Chest High Putters

rated by 0 users
Fri, May 24 2013 4:15 AM (15 replies)
  • PAGES
  • 1
  • 2
  • Geahry1
    525 Posts
    Wed, May 22 2013 6:41 PM

    Hello Wgt can we get Chest High Putters.Very cool if we could.

  • courteneyfish
    15,796 Posts
    Wed, May 22 2013 10:17 PM

    Hardly worth it as they are to be banned soon.

  • jeepie411
    3,197 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 5:00 AM

    Even if they were not going to be banned I highly doubt that WGT would reprogram the avatars to accept the different movements associated with the anchored putters. That is unless they could sell them for 500k in credits

  • lonnieskinner
    1,677 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 6:14 AM

    The long putter is not getting banned. Only anchoring of them to the torso.

  • jeepie411
    3,197 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 7:23 AM

    The long putter is not banned but the way the top pros use it is. against the chest as an anchoring stroke will be prohibited as all the top pros who use the long putter do. Case in point is Adam Scott.

     

    I very much doubt that anyone will be using this on the PGA without the anchoring on some part of the body. Thus WGT will surely not do the programming required for this game.

  • srellim234
    2,077 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 8:23 AM

    Matt Kuchar using his  45" belly putter anchored against his forearm instead of belly will still be ok.

  • Jimbog1964
    8,378 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 9:11 AM

    Being anchored directly or indirectly is the key:

  • Timbo1984
    818 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 11:39 AM

    Just to throw something else into the mix...(apologies for being off topic a bit)

    Being a fairly avid golfer with a low handicap, have any of you ever tried to use a belly putter, or even one of the broom handle putters?

    If like me, you have only used a conventional putter, it is absurdly difficult to adjust to that achored style of putting.

    When putting they try to teach you to only use your arms and follow through in an arch with your shoulders and stiff left wrist, but just about every golfer will tell you there is body movement involved and a little turning of the hips and chest when putting.

    An achorned putter puts your normal understanding of putting out the window, that small amount of body movement takes your alignment with the ball way out of sync. 

    Basically the point I am trying to arrive at here is that the pending law coming into golf is a little absurd, and based primarily on major results. Case in point as mentioned above is Adam Scott. Seeing a few players coming outside of the traditional favoured circle of winners made people think that perhaps there is something to this anchored style of putting that is giving an advantage to these individuals. This could not be further from the truth in my eyes at least, as some of these little-known major winner went on to be highly competitive after there big wins, meaning they were already very talented we only found out about them because they won and the common belief is that it was an anchored putter that gave them that edge.

    Anyone else feel the same way, or opposite to my opinions?

    Also I agree that it would make very little sense for WGT to have these putters, anchored or not. It would look awkward and take alot of time to program without having any real benefit from a gaming perspective. As well as the fact that we all have the perfect swing and putting style in this game, its the "ding" thats the real divider.

  • Jimbog1964
    8,378 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 11:55 AM

    Timbo1984:
    Also I agree that it would make very little sense for WGT to have these putters,

    For a computer game, just looks. Agreed no point.

    Timbo1984:
    anchored putter that gave them that edge.

    I understand the main issue is the yips at the very top level. That last point from Colin Montgomerie, in the cauldron of Home advantage Detroit, to clinch the Ryder Cup in 04 he say's was made easier because anchoring eases nerves. In the end I think it's as simple as that governing body wise any way! They won't say that directly preferring to spiel about freedom of body movement and so on! Amateur wise it will trundle on for a while I suspect, until lack of investment possibly sees it tailing off........maybe?

     

  • alanti
    10,564 Posts
    Thu, May 23 2013 1:30 PM

    Timbo1984:

    Being a fairly avid golfer with a low handicap, have any of you ever tried to use a belly putter, or even one of the broom handle putters?

    A very good post and for a change a sensible and pragmatic attitude towards these putters. I too am a low handicap player and did try one of  the belly putters after a round of poor putting. My thoughts from a short practice that they did make the short 3-5 foot putts easier, but longer putts I totally lacked any feel - advantage negated in my view.

    As you said, is the banning of such putters a knee jerk reaction? Again I think it is and equate this to some of the security changes within the aviation industry which have never actually made the skies any safer - but thats another rant lol.

    As for the "unknown" players rising to the top in the majors (and as far as I was concerned, Adam Scott was far from inknown) I agree, these are all great players and this shows how competitive the PGA Tour is - anyone is capable of winning. Have they won a tournament just because of the long putter? No, but putting is where a top player earns their keep.

    These putters have been around for a long time now, but as Timbo says, the spotlight is now on due to the Major successes. So by the same token, what happens if only players with a wild inside/out swing starts winning all the Majors, would that then be banned? These putters are now part of golf, conformed to the rules so why make the changes IMO.

    For this game, Jeepie nailed it, the avatar changes would be to difficult.

    And for the record, personally I dislike these putters, but as I do not think they give a real advantage but isn't having a choice a good thing. On a lighter note, who wants to look like a dork on a course with a Giraffe-like club sticking out their bag?

     

  • PAGES
  • 1
  • 2
RSS