Hi EK and I agree with PJ, there is no best. Putters are a personal thing but whatever you go for - stick with it.
I use the upper level Method and personally love it. The only downside is putts under 10 feet have to be hit harder - again if you buy it, stick with it and you soon learn. I used the Odyssey (and a couple of other putters) on the free rental weekend. Performance wise was similar to the Method. The thing I did not like was the scale - after using the Nike 10/20 scale the calculations on 15/30 got confusing - but this may work better with what you are used to.
There is one thing I will advise, and that is to think about getting a third wedge. Your GIR are poor and so are your scrambling stats, and a third wedge will help, and also help get the ball closer to the pin. And really work on the scrambling.
Note - I am a "ding" putter (well try to be lol) and the Method works well with this
Edit - Further to the Max lovers, this was one I tried as well as the top Ghost. As above the Max was preferred option due to the scale increments for me - but that is one ugly mother of a putter lol. Looked like a hockey stick on the green. So I willstick with the Nike.