Weirdly, I'd have to go with ARod007 on this one. He may not run a great tourney (sorry), but it always seems to be honest about this scores.
Although, I say this, Charlie1234 may well be telling the truth, and I've just read ARod007 wrong. Hm....
Either way, I don't feel that either player should go though until this matter is sorted fairly.
Just my 1p.