I believe you should get another chance. You have replays that clearly show something major was wrong and it was unbeknownst to you at the time. With that being said, this little excerpt lives in the Terms & Conditions:
(1) & (2) left out, they do not apply.
(3) By starting a beta game, you agree that:
(i) playing beta games is at your own risk and that you know that the
games may include known or unknown bugs, (ii) any value or status
indicators that you achieve through game play may be erased at any
time, (iii) WORLD GOLF TOUR (WGT) has no obligation to make these games
available, (iv) WORLD GOLF TOUR's Terms & Conditions apply to your
use of the games during the testing phase, and (v) if it is a private
beta test, you will keep all information about the beta games
confidential as stated above and not disclose such information to any
other person.
Yay for technicalities. :-/
Again Alex, even with that being present in the T's & C's, I think a special exception should be made in this case under these particular circumstances. This wasn't a minor bug. This was a pretty big oops. That's my two cents anyway. Good Luck Caven.