EARTHWALKER: Is this a good choice of mine or are their better ones for my level (37)?
I used that Anser for a long time when it first came out. I thought it was a good putter and before you give up on it, try switching to a ball that slows the meter down. The GI series balls do this and won't break the bank.
Even if you do decide to switch putters you're still going to have to learn it and that takes a while. You know what you have now so slow that meter down a little and see if that doesn't help first. GL