Forums

Help › Forums

Deleted Post

rated by 0 users
Wed, Jun 19 2013 8:11 PM (14 replies)
  • PAGES
  • 1
  • 2
  • borntobesting
    9,772 Posts
    Wed, Jun 19 2013 11:59 AM

    hpurey:
    Just my guess, but RSG is wide open land, and Oak has trees to block some wind.

    That is my belief as well. I feel WGT programmed the game so that barriers like trees and large buildings like the huge hotel on #17 @ St. Andrews affect the winds. They do in real life. 

  • oneeyedjohn
    9,589 Posts
    Wed, Jun 19 2013 12:39 PM

    SamanthaWho:

    A 20 mph wind on RSG is actually different than the same 20 mph wind at Oakmont. So yes. Why? I have no idea, it just is.

    Have never seen 20 mph wind at Oak, as at Oly, the max is 19 mph

  • gr8flbob
    592 Posts
    Wed, Jun 19 2013 7:08 PM

    oneeyedjohn:
    Have never seen 20 mph wind at Oak, as at Oly, the max is 19 mph

    Even in practice, with wind = 'High'?

    In WGT-land wind is a variable, both in direction and in strength - my estimate is 20% either way. Wind is also impacted by trees and terrain - that is impact of wind will vary by course played and the conditions of the shot you're facing.

  • alanti
    10,564 Posts
    Wed, Jun 19 2013 7:54 PM

    gr8flbob:
    In WGT-land wind is a variable, both in direction and in strength - my estimate is 20% either way. Wind is also impacted by trees and terrain - that is impact of wind will vary by course played and the conditions of the shot you're facing.

    I agree that many elements have an impact on the wind, so whilst it ma be a 20mph wind, different courses produce different results.

    Links courses in general are very difficult to gauge the wind, and what is blowing at the tee may be totally different on around the green or vice versa. They usually have few trees but can be sheltered by the terrain and even subtle gradients seem to make a difference. So I think WGT have tried to replicate this, so the wind strength may be the same (the OP's question) but the effects are different.

    I remember playing in Scotland once, tee was blowing a gale, slight downhill par three, I teed off and could see the ball moving a lot in the wind, as it came down the ball just sailed and sailed on against the wind, when I was walking to the green there was hardly no wind and I was 30 yards long in deep chit. So whilst the wind was still howling, it had no effect as the ball dropped below majority of the wind. Of course you can get the reverse with "upwinds" similar to sheer in an aircraft.

  • PAGES
  • 1
  • 2
RSS