Hi,
I went from a G20 level 58 to this and saw an immediate improvement. Now, with such a big jump one would expect that. I cant say how it would compare to other highest level 3woods, but I have found it very user friendly.
However, I do share your concern that the forgiveness is not what it's cracked up to be. I also notice that though the meter is nice and slow, which is what I wanted b4 I bought it and was a big part of my decision process, it does as you say seem to accelerate thru the ding zone quite fast, meaning more ding misses than one would expect with a slow meter club.
Having said that, I birdie most par 5's now. On a par 5 9hole round, 36-37 is what I expect unless it's super windy. And I usually play with a cheap style of ball without the mega spin of nike, 2 dots at the most.
Like you say, keep practicing, it can only help.
AFD