YankeeJim: Absolutely not. The punch is fine exactly the way it is, has been for over 5 years.
YankeeJim, looks like we disagree here. I do agree that the punch is not bad and could be worse, but the more I hear about wgt going for more of the reality aspect of the game, the more I think it needs to be tweaked some to become closer to how a real punch shot plays.
First of all, a punch shot, if hit properly, should not get very high as many do here. A punch is used, most often, to get out of trouble spots like off the FW among trees. When it's hit right, it's almost like a line-drive in baseball. A straight, low shot with a lot of top spin and roll. They do roll here, but at times I find myself with a shot I know a true punch could make, but with the height they get here some shots that should be possible to make just are not.
So, I guess I only half disagree with you here. And, truth be told, it isn't often I get in the situation where keeping the ball very low is needed. At least not like I used to.
How about we make a deal? I'll give up on the punch shot if wgt will make a shot available that can hit out of brush. It's so sad when one shot in the brush turns into 3 more from the brush and there goes your round. I'm not asking to be able to hit the ball 175 yards and land it a foot from the pin, but just let me hit it 100 yards forward, at the very least.