We just had this discussion in the CC forum.....
A TL was trying to decide whether or not to buy it...3 other TL's(all very good players) have it and like it...the player who has had it the longest said he averages about 4 yrds longer than the 8 degree R1, but what he likes most is the carry...they all love it...
I have the Nike and R1, and I rented the new longer R1...I couldn't get used to the slow slow meter LOL...I did see a few more yrds like the other TL said, but I prefer the Nike 9 degree...
The reason I like it as I have posted many times before, is the same reason Tom likes the new R1...it isn't the 4 yrds longer avg...it is the fact that the higher loft is more versatile, you can cut corners and go over trees that you cant with the old R1...and when you do, you gain a 15-25 yrd advantage on these holes....
It is all about getting used to the one you play with...I wouldn't buy it for a couple of yrds as I can already use the carry with the nike....the other 3-4 guys with the old R1 love it!