Hi Giantfan,My advice for what it is worth:Change your clubs,the starter clubs are way better than the beginners and are free.The meter is a little faster but with a bit of practice!!! I would advise keeping the beginner putter esp since you can hole 54 footers!
Your driving 78% is good,putts inside 5 ft nearly 50% fine,approach shots at 30%,try the starter clubs,they will help!
Match play 0 don't be shy give it a try,you can learn a lot from other players,even more so in Alt shot,As you improve,you will find these bizarre inexplicaple shots will happen less.Just like in real life and real golf there will always be freaks of nature(tree Rats with avg Kahunas!),it's all about the Karma!
Kind Regards Bob