jocko63: thing is starter clubs.. higher avgs ... still shoot 57? can I watch that round..? I am master with good clubs but no way shoot 57..try all the time and still cant come ciose...somethings up
Others have already addressed the ability of some to shoot in the 50s. There's not anything necessarily "up" with someone who shoots that low of a score.
But I did look at the player who I believe you're referring to. I have to agree that something seems a bit odd there. The player has 1 friend and yet is part of a country club. But when you look at the CC, there's little activity by the members, and (IIRC) everyone is listed as a recruit. All of that seems odd.
And you're correct. The person's clubs are not ones that you would expect of a person who shoots a 58. But it's possible that he caught lightning in a bottle for one round and went low. It happens.
I once shot a 26 on the back 9 of Royal St. George's from the tips (tournament greens) in pretty high winds. Also, I have a 59 on Oakmont (championship tees and greens). And I'm not that great. Every once in a while, a round will come together for me.