Forums

Help › Forums

Deviations Presents - A Country Club Challenge

Wed, Oct 5 2011 3:57 PM (223 replies)
  • lvietri
    3,326 Posts
    Sun, Sep 18 2011 6:02 PM

    Hi all ... I'll update everything on Monday night Eastern Time as I will be playing golf all day Monday.

    I do have updates from Deviations, Transgressional, Elite and English Lakes as they captains have sent me their current scores.   They are included in the attached link.   Barring any late entries these teams are all way behind where I expect Electra to come in.   They did a bang up job.   It's my guess that Carolina will be right in the mix for 2nd through 6th place also with the above mentioned teams.

    Click Here     ----- Go to the tab titled week 3 for the details (on bottom).

    For those of you starting this weeks tournament at St Andrews ... Good Luck.

    Lou

  • FarFoo
    2,920 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 2:02 AM

    lvietri:
    It's my guess that Carolina will be right in the mix for 2nd through 6th place also with the above mentioned teams.

    I think I previously had them in the mix for 2nd but I think I was wrong. Turns out they are using the results to recruit active, good quality members.

    Smart move for an expanding CC.

    Foo

     

  • TC9495
    1,219 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 2:46 AM

    Not such a good week for Cosa Nostra;

    Deviations Presents - A Country Club Challenge
    Week 3
    Owner Caicailee    
    Captain TC9495    
    CC Cosa Nostra    
      Player Tier Score
    1 frogstachio Tour Master 61
    2 FRIENDofyourWIFE Legend 62
    3 LuisCraveiro Legend 63
    4 Turtle35 Legend 63
    5 JKR700 Tour Master 63
    6 Custiss13 Tour Master 63
    7 Egotrippin Master 63
    8 DrussTheLegend Legend 64
    9 hooks4u2 Tour Master 64
    10 whinsoul Legend 65
    Total     631

  • flaccus
    516 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 3:12 AM

    18CCC

    WK38 Kiawa Moderate wind

    Normans Webb collective

    1. 61 GonzoCPL Tour Master
    2. 63 Wayne67 Master ( TOP DOG once upon a time) 
    3. 63 Fortesque99 Legend 
    4. 64 Flaccus Legend
    5. 66 Binkle Master 
    6. 66 GoHardGoHome Legend
    7. 67 Witto Legend
    8. 68 Burney75 Tour Master 
    9. 68 Hef111 Legend
    10. 69 Taswegion Master

    TOTAL: 655

    AVE: 65.5

  • lvietri
    3,326 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 4:01 AM

    Thanks for reporting gents.   I have final scores for 6 teams + the to party crashers.   I have preliminary scores for Electra and I still need scores from Carolina Sandhills.   This one is close ... check things out on the main scoreboard.

    Click Here

    Final results will be posted tonight after I get back from Golf.

    Tks all

  • Dianne81
    773 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 11:49 AM

    lvietri:

     

    In the spirit of fairness and sportsmanship - our club will not count the scores of these 2 of these players (Suncity28 and Win1Soon)  during in this tournament.    The other 2 (TheLighterDark and TarHeelsRule) ... will only count after week 4 has been completed ... since they were in the process of being inducted for 8 weeks and are anxious to be part of the club. 

    We will not ask the other clubs participating to do this.  You can bring players on and start counting them any time you like.   This is something that as the host club we feel we should do.

    Good luck to everyone.

     

     Again, great job on the tourney !!  Because of what you putting together the country club competition, the weekly singles is a  round I look forward to participating in every week.

    This is my  opinion of you benching some of your new talent. Deviations is full of incredible players, and constantly at the top. I applaud your fairness and sportsmanship, but would love to see you include the top 10 scores of all your current membership.

    I think it would only be unfair to include their scores only if they were posted before becoming a member of your country club. For example if player had posted a score in weekly single before becoming a member, then that score shouldnt be allowed to count in that particular week, (that would be like picking your fantasy football team for the week after all the games had been played LOL ) but all future weeks Id LOVE to see them allowed to participate.

    Its doubtful any other club would be able to dethrone you guys at Deviations, but if one did, it would be an empty victory knowing that you guys didnt count all the top 10 scores from eligible members of your club.

    Just my .02

    Thanks again for all you do

    Dianne

  • mreddy
    895 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 12:16 PM

    Congrats to heffdiddy of the Carolina Sandhills with an awesome score of 56 , it should help us in the standings this week .

    heffdiddy 56  , Gucho  60  ,  BrianSJMA  61  , crunchyb  61  , barfly99  61 , KANE09  61  , fledgling1  62 ,  pharaohe 62 , hightower3  62  , tearbear  62

    Great Job Everyone 

  • TallAcePaul
    1,455 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 12:21 PM

    Dianne, I am in absolute agreement with you. Members join and leave clubs all the time, there was no ruling in this competition that members who joined during the competition could not partake in it. As long as that person is a member at the time of playing the comp their score stands.

    I think that is overly generous of you Lou. We are thinking of inviting God to join the ELCC as we may need his help and I hope there will be no objections to this!

  • FarFoo
    2,920 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 12:53 PM

    mreddy:

    Congrats to heffdiddy of the Carolina Sandhills with an awesome score of 56 , it should help us in the standings this week .

    Totally agree on that, fantastic round heffdiddy.

    mreddy:

    heffdiddy 56  , Gucho  60  ,  BrianSJMA  61  , crunchyb  61  , barfly99  61 , KANE09  61  , fledling  62 ,  pharaohe 62 , hightower3  62  , tearbear  62

    Great Job Everyone , Thanks for putting us up top !

    Ed

    Hmmmm... Think we may need to wait for the judge & Jury on that one Ed.

    Foo

  • BradySeven
    647 Posts
    Mon, Sep 19 2011 12:54 PM

    I have to agree with Dianne as well, there's no reason why players scores shouldn't count provided they were a member of the club at the time of playing. I think however that we do need a clear ruling on the Carolina Sandhills scores submitted above. Six of these players joined the club AFTER they posted their scores. These scores surely can't be allowed to count this week??

RSS