ScottHope:
You might have to use your graphics card software or other screen recording program to capture gameplay moments nowadays.
You are not alone in your dilemma, there hasn't been an entry in the Best Replay thread in nearly a year now
The Windows + G (game console) works with steam. You can use this, if you are on PC. I can use this to record shots.
So, just to revive the Best Replay thread, I am going to post 2 in that thread this morning. A flop for Eagle on Merion 1 and a near double Eagle on #11 Kiah...