I find the percent affects my shot more 1st, if its an eagle, birdie, or just trying to save Par. it may be just me...lol
But every course reacts differently and so does the green speeds, so say where a pitch/chip hit strong may work on one, its useless on another and yes a flop would have been the correct option!
My best advice would be to take notes on each course on index cards, the rough % , the green speed ! distance/elevation, club & shot type used, then maybe chart outcome so the next time you can club up/down and know how hard to hit the shot, type of shot and the best club for the best outcome.
Still with WGT & VEM its a roll of the dice but I wish you much success ! we all get frustrated at times with wtf shots, keep at it ! and hope I have helped in some small way !